Captain Jay Charters Reviews – Marathon, Florida Keys
When it comes to Marathon fishing charters, few names carry the reputation and consistency of Captain Jay Charters. Based out of the Key Fisheries Marina at Mile Marker 49, this charter service has earned a 5.0 ★ rating across 300+ Google reviews, along with near‑perfect scores on FishingBooker and Facebook.
Guests highlight the blend of family‑friendly fishing trips, professional captains, and versatile adventures from offshore fishing in the Gulf Stream to snorkeling at Sombrero Reef. Whether you’re chasing mahi, grouper, or tarpon, or simply looking for a fun day on the water with kids, Captain Jay Charters delivers a tailored experience that feels personal and memorable.
With a diverse fleet including the 30’ Mako, 25’ Sea Hunt, 34’ Venture, 23’ Parker, and the premium 36’ Grady White Express, every trip is designed to match your group’s needs, budget, and fishing style. Add in extras like catch cleaning, vacuum sealing, and “cook your catch” referrals, and it’s easy to see why this charter is considered one of the best fishing experiences in the Florida Keys.
About Captain Jay Charters
Captain Jay Charters is more than just a fishing service; it’s a locally rooted operation in Marathon, Florida Keys, built on years of experience and a passion for tailoring every trip to the group on board. Captain Jason and his team pride themselves on personalized adventures, ensuring that no two charters are ever the same. Before each trip, the crew works directly with guests to understand their goals, whether it’s chasing trophy fish offshore, introducing kids to their first snapper, or combining fishing with snorkeling and island hopping.
The Fleet
Captain Jay Charters operates one of the most versatile fleets in Marathon, giving guests options that match their style, group size, and budget:
- 30’ Mako – A reliable choice for reef, wreck, and family trips.
- 25’ Sea Hunt – Perfect for smaller groups and inshore adventures.
- 34’ Venture – Built for extended offshore runs and larger parties.
- 23’ Parker – Budget‑friendly option for short trips and shark fishing.
- 36’ Grady White Express – Premium comfort with AC cabin and bathroom, ideal for serious offshore anglers who want luxury amenities.
Tailored Experiences
Every trip is customized to maximize enjoyment and success:
- Families benefit from kid‑friendly fishing trips with patient instruction.
- Adventurers can head offshore for big game species like tuna, mahi, and sailfish.
- Nature lovers enjoy snorkeling at Sombrero Reef and island hopping.
- Seasonal anglers target tarpon during peak months (Feb–May).
Trust & Preparation
Guests never have to worry about gear or logistics. Captain Jay Charters provides:
- Top‑of‑the‑line Penn reels and Esky custom rods
- Live bait, tackle, and fishing licenses
- Catch cleaning and filleting, plus vacuum sealing and shipping options
- Referrals to Marathon restaurants that offer cook your catch service
Customer Reviews & Reputation
Captain Jay Charters has earned a 5.0 ★ rating on Google with over 300 reviews, along with near‑perfect scores on FishingBooker and Facebook. This consistent reputation makes it one of the most trusted names among Marathon fishing charters. Guests highlight the charter’s ability to deliver high catch rates, a family‑friendly atmosphere, and a crew that balances professionalism with fun.
What Guests Love
- Knowledgeable Captains – Captains Jay, Austin, Bryce, Casey, and Randy are praised for patience, adaptability, and making trips enjoyable for beginners and seasoned anglers alike.
- Kid-Friendly Trips – Families consistently mention how children are engaged, taught fishing basics, and kept safe throughout the day.
- Comfortable Boats – Reviews highlight shaded seating, restrooms, and the luxury AC cabin aboard the Grady White Express.
- Catch Cleaning Service – Guests appreciate that fish are cleaned, filleted, and bagged, ready for grilling or restaurant “cook your catch” service.
Common Praise
- “We had an amazing time with Captain Jay! He is awesome and made everything super fun and easy for us!”
- “By far the best experience I’ve had to date!”
- “Captain Randy was great and knew where to go to find the fish.”
Considerations
Like any fishing charter, trips are weather-dependent. Guests note that the crew communicates clearly about conditions and adjusts plans to keep the day safe and enjoyable.
Captain Jay Fishing Charters Marathon – Types of Fishing Trips
Captain Jay Charters offers one of the most diverse lineups in the Florida Keys fishing charter scene, ensuring there’s a trip for every type of angler, from families with kids to seasoned offshore veterans.
Offshore Fishing
- Runs 10–60 miles into the Gulf Stream.
- Targets big game species like tuna, mahi mahi, sailfish, and wahoo.
- Seasonal migrations mean every trip can bring a different mix of fish.
- Perfect for anglers seeking adrenaline and trophy catches.
Reef & Wreck Fishing
- Focuses on reefs and coral patches around Marathon.
- Common catches: snapper (mangrove, mutton, yellowtail), grouper, kingfish.
- Wrecks in 100–400 ft of water provide artificial reef habitats.
- Techniques include drifting or anchoring, depending on wind and current.
Tarpon Fishing
- Seasonal (Feb–May), targeting tarpon around bridges.
- Known for acrobatic fights and thrilling runs.
- Live bait is used to maximize hook‑ups.
- A bucket‑list experience for many visiting anglers.
Family Trips
- Designed for kids and beginners.
- Calm water options are available for comfort.
- Patient instruction ensures children learn while having fun.
- Great way to spend quality vacation time outdoors.
Fish, Snorkel & Island Hop
- Combines fishing with snorkeling at Sombrero Reef.
- Explore coral formations and schools of tropical fish.
- Includes sandbar stops and sightseeing around the Keys.
- Ideal for groups who want variety beyond fishing.
Lobster Trips
- Seasonal lobster diving and harvesting.
- Available as half‑day or ¾‑day trips.
- Popular among families and food lovers looking for a unique Keys experience.
Each trip includes gear, bait, tackle, licenses, bottled water, and catch cleaning, making it easy for guests to focus on fun and fishing.
Pricing & Boats
Captain Jay Charters offers a wide range of boats and trip options, making it one of the most versatile choices among Marathon fishing charters. Whether you’re looking for a budget‑friendly family outing or a luxury offshore adventure, the fleet and pricing structure are designed to fit different needs, group sizes, and fishing styles.
30’ Mako
- 3 hr Family Trip – $650
- ½ Day Reef/Wreck/Gulf – $800
- ½ Day Snorkel/Island Hop – $750
- ½ Day Shark Trip – $800
- ½ Day Tarpon (Feb–May) – $700
- ¾ Day Offshore – $1200
- Full Day Offshore – $1400
(Fuel surcharge not included)
25’ Sea Hunt
- 3 hr Trip – $600
- 4 hr Inshore/Reef – $700
- 6 hr Inshore/Reef – $850
- 8 hr Full Day – $1200
- 4 hr Lobster Trip – $700
- 6 hr Lobster Trip – $800
34’ Venture
- ½ Day Reef/Wreck/Gulf – $950
- ¾ Day Reef/Wreck – $1300
- Full Day Reef/Wreck – $1650
- ¾ Offshore Trip – $1500
- Full Day Offshore – $2100
- 10 hr Offshore Extended – $2600
- 10 hr Far Gulf Long Range – $2700
(Fuel surcharge not included)
23’ Parker
- 3 hr Trip – $600
- 3 hr Shark/Cuda/Goliath Grouper – $600
- 4 hr Snorkel/Sandbar – $650
- 4 hr Inshore/Reef – $700
- 6 hr Reef/Inshore/Bay – $850
36’ Grady White Express
- Premium vessel with AC cabin & bathroom
- 3 hr Trip – $1095
- ½ Day Reef/Wreck – $1295
- ¾ Day Reef/Wreck – $1895
- ¾ Day Offshore – $2195
- Full Day Offshore – $2700
Notes
- All trips include gear, bait, tackle, licenses, bottled water, and catch cleaning.
- Fuel surcharge applies to offshore trips.
- Seasonal tarpon trips available Feb–May.
Species You Can Catch
One of the biggest draws of Captain Jay Charters is the sheer variety of fish available in the waters around Marathon, Florida Keys. Whether you’re staying close to the reef or heading deep into the Gulf Stream, every trip offers a chance to reel in something exciting.
Inshore Species
- Snapper – Lane, Mangrove, Mutton, Yellowtail
- Spanish Mackerel – fast‑moving and fun for beginners
- Grouper – Black and Goliath varieties thrive near reefs and coral patches
Nearshore Species
- Mangrove Snapper – popular for family trips and great eating
- Yellowtail Snapper – abundant around reefs and wrecks
Offshore Species
- Tuna – thrilling runs and prized catches
- Sailfish – acrobatic fighters, a true sportfishing highlight
- Mahi Mahi – colorful, fast, and delicious
- Wahoo – known for speed and challenge
Specialty Species
- Tarpon – seasonal (Feb–May), famous for acrobatics near bridges
- Barracuda – aggressive strikes, exciting for adventurous anglers
- Sharks – Bull and Nurse sharks targeted on dedicated trips
Post‑Trip Options
Every catch is cleaned and filleted by the crew. Guests can:
- Grill their fish immediately after the trip
- Take advantage of the cook-your-catch restaurants in Marathon
- Use vacuum sealing and shipping services to enjoy fresh fish at home
Trip Inclusions
One of the reasons Captain Jay Charters earns such strong reviews is the way every trip is fully equipped and stress‑free. Guests don’t need to worry about gear, permits, or logistics; everything is prepared in advance so you can focus on enjoying the day on the water.
What’s Provided
- Fishing Licenses – All permits are covered, so guests don’t need to arrange paperwork.
- Top‑Quality Gear – Penn reels, Esky custom rods, live bait, and tackle included.
- Catch Cleaning – Fish are cleaned, filleted, and bagged free of charge.
- Vacuum Sealing & Shipping – Optional service to send your fresh catch home.
- Cook Your Catch Referrals – Local restaurants in Marathon prepare your fish for dinner.
- Comfort Amenities – Bottled water, shaded seating, restroom facilities, and AC cabin on the Grady White Express.
What Guests Should Bring
- Sunscreen, hats, and sunglasses for sun protection
- Snacks and drinks (water provided on board)
- Comfortable clothing suitable for fishing and snorkeling
Why It Matters
By including everything from licenses to gear, Captain Jay Charters removes the hassle of preparation. This makes it especially appealing for family fishing trips and visitors who want a seamless experience in the Florida Keys.
Booking & Policies
Booking with Captain Jay Charters is straightforward, but because of their popularity in Marathon, Florida Keys, it’s highly recommended to reserve your trip well in advance.
How to Book
- Reserve directly through the official website or via FishingBooker.
- Call the captain at [+1 917‑846‑2170] for personalized trip planning.
- Trips depart from Key Fisheries Marina, Mile Marker 49, Marathon, FL 33050.
Cancellation Policy
- 61+ days notice – Cancel without penalty.
- Within 60 days – Deposit is forfeited.
- Within 72 hours (3 days) – Full payment charged.
- No‑shows – Charged in full.
Why It Matters
Clear policies and direct communication build trust. Guests appreciate that the crew is upfront about weather conditions and flexible when adjustments are needed. This transparency is one reason Captain Jay Charters maintains such strong reviews across platforms.
| Feature | Captain Jay Charters | Two Conchs Charters | SeaSquared Charters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 5.0 ★ (Google, 300+ reviews) | 4.5 ★ (Google, 1,240+ reviews) | 4.7 ★ (TripAdvisor, 447 reviews) |
| Fleet Size | 5 boats (Mako, Sea Hunt, Venture, Parker, Grady White Express) | Large multi‑boat fleet, many captains | 6 boats (SeaSquared XL, Blue Magic, Top Notch, Wayne’s World, SeaSquared Too) |
| Family Friendly | Yes, strong kid‑friendly focus | Yes, patient with beginners | Yes, highly rated for family trips |
| Specialty | Variety: offshore, reef, wreck, tarpon, snorkel/island hop | Reef, bay, wreck, offshore trips | Variety + family trips |
| Unique Offering | Luxury Grady White Express with AC cabin | Wide range of captains and trip types | “Dinner & A Show” shark + snapper combo |
| Pricing | Flexible: $600–$2700 depending on boat/trip | US$800–900 per group (up to 6 passengers) | Mid‑to‑high range |
Conclusion
Captain Jay Charters stands out as one of the top‑rated fishing charters in Marathon, Florida Keys, blending professionalism, family‑friendly service, and consistent success on the water. With a 5.0 ★ reputation across Google, FishingBooker, and Facebook, guests repeatedly highlight the crew’s patience, knowledge, and ability to tailor trips for every type of angler, from kids catching their first snapper to seasoned fishermen chasing offshore trophies.
The diverse fleet from the 30’ Mako to the luxury 36’ Grady White Express ensures there’s a boat and trip style for every budget and preference. Add in extras like catch cleaning, vacuum sealing, and referrals to cook your catch restaurants, and it’s clear why Captain Jay Charters is considered a trusted choice for both families and serious anglers.
For anyone planning a trip to the Keys, booking early is highly recommended to secure your preferred adventure. Whether it’s offshore fishing, reef and wreck trips, or a family‑friendly snorkel and island hop, Captain Jay Charters delivers a safe, fun, and memorable day on the water.
FAQs – Captain Jay Charters Reviews
What species can I catch with Captain Jay Charters?
You can target snapper, grouper, Spanish mackerel, and tarpon inshore. Offshore trips chase tuna, mahi mahi, sailfish, and wahoo.
Are trips suitable for kids and beginners?
Yes. Captain Jay Charters specializes in family fishing trips, with patient captains who make the experience fun and safe for children of all ages.
What is included in the charter price?
Trips include fishing licenses, bait, tackle, Penn reels, Esky rods, bottled water, and catch cleaning.
Do I need to bring my own gear?
No. All gear is provided. Guests only need to bring sunscreen, hats, sunglasses, and any snacks or drinks they prefer.
How does the cancellation policy work?
- 61+ days notice: No penalty
- Within 60 days: Deposit forfeited
- Within 72 hours: Full payment charged
- No‑shows: Charged in full
Which boat is best for offshore trips?
The 36’ Grady White Express is ideal for luxury offshore fishing with an AC cabin and bathroom. The 34’ Venture is another strong choice for extended Gulf Stream runs.
Can I snorkel and fish on the same trip?
Yes. The Fish, Snorkel & Island Hop package combines reef fishing with snorkeling at Sombrero Reef and sandbar stops.
How do I book a trip in advance?
You can book directly via the official site or through FishingBooker.
Is fish cleaning included?
Yes. The crew cleans and fillets your catch free of charge. Vacuum sealing and shipping are also available.
Where can I eat my catch in Marathon?
Several local restaurants offer cook-your-catch service, turning your fresh fish into a delicious meal the same day.